Wanted to pass to the Team at Fort Myers the great job that Matt Pendleton is doing. I reached out to Culbertson's and Matt responded and has been working with me doing a great job. He is professional, courteous, on top of issues. He has been following up on details and keeping my interests in mind. Things have been going so well I went and actually got another coverage for another property I had due to his great work. Wanted to make sure the firm/site is aware of the great representation Matt is doing for you and a reason I've felt I made the right decision in going to Culbertson's Agency. Thanks Culbertson!


It's actually been "my" pleasure working with your company & more importantly Scott!!! He was referred to me by my parents who currently have insurance with your company and have worked closely with Scott!!! They are elderly & he took the time to meet with them & make sure their needs were met! He's a true asset to your company!!!


Your agency is different in a "good" way. Your staff is efficient, thorough, straightforward and communicative. Information was conveyed in an understandable way and I appreciate that. Thank you for your help at a time when I was frantic. My husband and I have lived in our home for 24 years and have used the same agency for that time period. It was time to make a change and again thanks to your staff we feel comfortable with the change.


We have been married for 47 years and have had renters, homeowners and car insurance for all those years. This is the first agency we felt really cared about us. Our agent David is so nice and understanding with our questions. The entire agency really cares about their customers. Having been in retail business for 50 years, I can tell you, this is very hard to find in any company. The Culbertson Agency makes Allstate look good.


We had honestly given up on finding an excellent insurance agency. We thought it was a thing of the past. We had been dealing with an old agency near downtown but went into Brian Culbertson’s office and talked with David Theiss about our needs. He had all the information we needed at his fingertips and showed us how we could save money and upgrades our policies as well. We have recommended them to our neighbors and continue to be very pleased. It’s the first time that we have felt that we actually had an insurance agency in many years.


I have told my neighbors about the great service and one has already moved their insurance to you. It is nice to be able to talk to someone and not get voicemail that is never returned. Everything I have asked for has been done immediately. I can't ask for more than that.


We are in-deed very happy to have you as our home owners insurance agent. You are true to yourself and to your customers and we really appreciate that. We believe that you will stay in business longer than others because of your sincerity to your customers. Your phrase, "Do to others as we would have them do to us " is quite appropriate here. Thank you and thanks to Mr. Matt Pendleton for his kindness to follow your footsteps in helping others for your company to stay in business in today's competitive world. 

 John and Maria

Hi Brian! I wanted to bring to your attention that I recently had the pleasure of working with Scott Ehrenfeld. From the very start, he was friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. Further, at the last moment, I was unable to go through with a policy that he had spent considerable time on due the company pet restrictions. However, his willingness to continue assistance and his sincerity was remarkable. Because of his actions, I will be referring friends and family to the Culbertson Agency!

 Natalie Coradetti

Brian,  I just wanted to let you know what a positive experience I just had as David wrote two Ins. policies for me.  He was so polite and patient with me as I really don't understand much about insurance.  You and your agents and staff truly project the "Do unto others"  attitude so very well.  Thanks for such a positive transaction. 


The owner is always ready to help if my normal agent has a customer and the receptionist is also knowledgeable in providing answers to simple questions and all are very friendly and willing to search out the answer to my questions if not on the top of their head!